vry

18 May 2006

Which South African language will survive

In a previous post, I wrote about the predicted demise of African languages in South Africa.
For a while I thought that perhaps the Prospect magazine article does not take into account the official status of some South African languages in our neighboring countries. I thought surely the survival of siSwati, Sesotho and Setswana are guaranteed because in countries where those languages are spoken by the vast majority of the population, and where they have official status, there should be no problem. I thought that these countries and their universities would eventually become the intellectual base for these languages, also for South Africans who speak siSwati, Sesotho and Setswana.
But what are the facts? I’m not keen to legitimize the CIA by using their “World Factbook”, but as a quick reference it is useful. According to the Factbook, the status is as follows:
Lesotho: English is the official language
Botswana: English is the official language
Swaziland: English (official, government business conducted in English), but siSwati is also official, though what that means is unclear if government business is English.

The situation on the ground might be different from what these facts suggest, but I will not be surprised if the Universities (and even schools) in these countries are English. This suggests to me that among South African languages, only Afrikaans has a desire to live. The others will still be around in at most 100 years. But I think they will be extinct in about 200 years.

14 May 2006

Too xenophobic and not competing for talent

Filed under: Africa Politics

In an article titled The Saga of the Returnee /Expatriate, the author, Frank Borteye, berates various Ghanaian attitudes.
He complains about laziness, envy, self imposed barriers to success, and especially, a bad attitude towards Ghanaians who became rich.
He writes about an urge to ’scheme and plan to pull the person down or discredit his wealth’. According to Borteye, Ghanaians would rather work for an abusive foreigner than for a Ghanaian.
This might all be true, and writing that article might be a useful thing to be doing, but it amazes me that he, who himself worked and made money as ‘a foreigner’ in the West, nonetheless seems to have a problem with foreigners in Ghana. Statements like “the Lebanese, Chinese, and Indians will take our birthplace” are pretty xenophopic, and what’s more, wrong - they contribute to Ghana’s economy and provide jobs.
One only needs to look at London, to see the prosperity and colour foreigners bring. People who migrated seem to have far more motivation and balls than the average local, so they tend to make things happen.
Even in London, business leaders are continuously begging for more skills. Africa is nowhere in the global race for skills - it doesn’t even have the psychological capability to acknowledge that it needs to compete in this race.
The author seems capable of joining a pro-imigration march in the US, but wanting to keep Ghana for the Ghanaians. When you go down the comments section at the bottom of that article, you see some far more shameless
xenophobia.
One of the comments:
“Wherever on earth the Indians are there are problems because they are clannish, racist and exploitative.They are not a good people. Ghanaians should follow Idi Amin`s example. Yes, the Ghanaian government should seize the assets of Indians, Chinese and Lebanese and deport them. These people are parasites.”
Xenophobia is also a major problem in SA, where Somalis were attacked in the past week.

5 May 2006

Further victories for colonialism

Filed under: Africa Politics

RW Johnson predicts in Prospect magazine that English will eventually exterminate most or even all the other ten languages in South Africa, including Afrikaans.
What a bitter and sad thought.
We are now so defeated that we do the bidding of imperialists without them lifting a finger or saying a word.

I would have liked to counter the article with some reason why our languages will survive, but at the moment I am without inspiration. Even in the future, colonialism seems set to continue defeating us even more.
And to think that Gordon Brown thought it acceptible to say that Britain should be proud of the empire. This is akin to saying a rapist should be proud of his deeds.
There are insights from psychology that seem to apply. There is something in our embrace of English that is akin to an abused woman repeatedly returning to her violent husband, or similar to Bettelheim’s 1943 observation that victims end up identifying with their aggressor.

It seems I am writing about colonialism a lot - I did not expect to do that, but it is what seems to flow..
Below are 2 links I hope to follow up about Britain’s ‘proud history of empire’:

Le Monde on the British Empire and todays apologists for it.
Al Jazeera on the Original Colonial Axis of Evil: The empires of Britain, France, and Belgium

But to end on a more positive note about English - at least it enables me to understand this:
“A liberal is a man too broadminded to take his own side in a quarrel.” - Robert Frost (1874-1963)

2 May 2006

How to keep up with Africa

Below is a list of news sources I try to keep up with. No single human can hope to read all that is written about Africa (my interest is in Southern Africa in particular), but I try to have a good go at it. I read a lot of comment - political punditry can be tiresome at times, (see this proper dissing of some columnists), but it summarises things. Even if you have missed a lot of news, you understand more or less what happened from reading a single opinion piece. And it gives a feel of the "political weather" in a place.
I also engage in opinion writing, in the spirit of the idea that bloggers will replace newspaper columnists as writers of opinion pieces
Even the list below is too much for me, and therefore I appreciate this really clever site (Muti). Whenever I read something notable (whether I agree with it or not, notable is the only requirement), I post it there, and crucially, others do the same. This digs up many interesting things I would not otherwise have read, and also gives me a quick fix if I haven’t had time for my many other news sources.

Non RSS news sources:

Afrol
Vryeafrikaan
Beeld
Rapport
Sunday Ttimes
Mail & Guardian
Business Day
City Press
Christian Science Monitor - Africa

Email:

African without Borders mailing list forum
Balancing act weekly newsletter
Africa Confidential.com weekly newsletter

RSS feeds:

http://www.tectonic.co.za/tectonic.rss
http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/index.xml
http://southafrica.blogspirit.com/index.rss
http://politics.za.net/xml/rss/feed.xml
http://www.fodder.co.za/rss.xml
http://jontyfisher.blogspot.com/atom.xml
http://vry.blogsome.com”>
http://commentary.co.za/feed/
http://www.monbiot.com/feed/rss2/
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/newsfeed/rss/opinion.xml
http://www.johnkay.com/rssfeed.xml
http://www.cato-unbound.org/feed/
http://www.opendemocracy.net/xml/rss/home/index.xml
http://africaunchained.blogspot.com/atom.xml
http://naijablog.blogspot.com/atom.xml
http://disasterafrica.blogspot.com/atom.xml
http://www.kenyanpundit.com/?feed=rss2
http://africanarchitecture.blogspot.com/atom.xml
http://sotho.blogsome.com/feed/
http://www.gfh.squarespace.com/journal/rss.xml
http://timbuktuchronicles.blogspot.com/atom.xml
http://www.voiceinthedesert.org.uk/weblog/index.xml
http://voiceinthedesert.netfirms.com/keith/index.xml
http://jpmozambique.blogspot.com/atom.xml
http://mzansiafrika.typepad.com/mzansi_afrika/rss.xml
http://www.sokwanele.com/thisiszimbabwe/feed/
http://news.bbc.co.uk/rss/newsonline_uk_edition/world/africa/rss091.xml
http://theconcoction.blogspot.com/atom.xml
http://kdiga.blogspot.com/atom.xml






















Get free blog up and running in minutes with Blogsome
Theme designed by Hadley Wickham